Yesterday’s High Court decision that the benefit cap is ‘unlawful’ for lone parents with children under the age of two is another blow to the Tories failing austerity agenda. It is failing on its own terms, it’s failing our communities, and it’s failing the most vulnerable in our country – including the victims of domestic violence and those facing homelessness.
The judgment handed down by Mr Justice Collins was damning. Upon considering the impact of the benefit cap, he concluded that “real misery is being caused to no good purpose.”
The Government’s claims that this ill-judged policy helps people transition from the social security system into paid work have been exposed as a myth. Seven out of eight households hit by the cap have very young children, are too ill to work or have a work-limiting disability. The spiralling cost of childcare has left many unable to find or afford good quality childcare in order to allow them to work. In some cases the will see some families lose up to £115 a week, pushing them into deeper into poverty.
Labour warned the Government of the impact this policy would have on lone parents with very young children during the passage of the Welfare Reform and Work Act and we tabled amendments to exempt lone parents with young children. They refused to listen and thousands of families have been pushed into poverty as a result, including survivors of domestic violence.
Many parents are perpetually stuck in insecure, poorly paid work on a zero hours contract, with the majority of their earnings spent on childcare. Alternatively they are unable to find work which fits around their childcare responsibilities and are then subjected to the benefit cap resulting in families struggling to make ends meet. Just under 320,000 children now live in households likely to be affected by the new lower cap which was introduced last November. This is at a time when one in four of our children are growing up in poverty.
Despite these obvious barriers facing families with young children, particularly lone parents, it has taken a brave group of campaigners to challenge a Government which lacked the foresight to see the real damage they are inflicting with another one of their disastrous austerity cuts. The Government’s own evaluations show that only 16% of families impacted by the benefit cap move into paid work compared to 11% who would have moved into work anyway.
For too long this Government has pushed our children into a lifetime of poverty, as punishment for their parent’s circumstances, whilst continuing to give hand-outs to the privileged few.
What a difference a year makes, only last July, the Prime Minister on the steps of Downing Street pledged to “fight the burning injustices” facing our society. Not only has she failed spectacularly, her Government continue to pursue policies that are further entrenching these injustices.
It is clear that the benefit cap hits the poorest in our society the hardest. This judgment is a further blow to Theresa May’s unstable minority government and I implore the Prime Minister to accept the High Court’s judgement and end this discriminatory policy against lone parent families.
This is the latest in a series of judgments found against the Government in relation to their austerity programme. After rulings on the bedroom tax, Personal Independence Payments and now the benefit cap the Government should now accept the ruling instead of spending yet more taxpayers’ money on an appeal.
Labour has proudly stood against the benefit cap, its discrimination against parents with young children and the Government’s cruel austerity programme which has caused too many people real misery.
A Labour government would immediately implement the High Court ruling and only a future Labour government will transform the social security system so that, like the NHS, it is there for the many in our time of need.